Attention Most Valued Customers: At this time, we have reached full capacity for orders to be delivered before Thanksgiving. You can continue to place your order on our website and you will be assigned a delivery date in line for the next available shipping date after the holiday. We will resume shipping on December 1st. If your delivery date does not work for you, please notify us so that we can assist you with a better date after the holiday. We appreciate your understanding as this is an extremely busy and difficult time for John Henry's. We are also experiencing a death in the family and appreciate your kindness and support during this season. This year, we are most thankful for you, our customers. Without your continued support, we would not be here.

Subtotal

$ 0.00

Cart is empty

Please add products to your cart.

Wishlist is empty

Please add products to your wishlist.

Compare list is empty

Please add products to compare.

Amish Butter Roll, HALF (1 lb.)

1 lb. The price is for 1/2 roll.
$ 7.50
0
+
-

Amish Butter Roll (2 lbs.)

2 lb. Price per roll.
$ 13.95
0
+
-

String Cheese

This Farm Country String Mozzerella is a tasty favorite for kids and adults alike!
$ 8.50
0
+
-

Pinconning Sharp Cheddar

Approximately .75 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly .75 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 10.49
0
+
-

Pinconning Extra Sharp Cheddar

Approximately .75 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly .75 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 11.24
0
+
-

Pinconning Mild Cheddar

Approximately .75 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly .75 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 9.74
0
+
-

Baby Swiss Cheese

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 12.99
0
+
-

Dill

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 8.59
0
+
-

Provolone

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 9.99
0
+
-

Muenster

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 10.99
0
+
-

Habanero

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 8.59
0
+
-

Hot Pepper

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 8.69
0
+
-

Mozzarella

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 10.99
0
+
-

Marble (Colby and Michigan Jack)

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 8.69
0
+
-

Colby

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 8.69
0
+
-

Onion & Garlic

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 8.59
0
+
-

Michigan Jack

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 8.49
0
+
-

Horseradish

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 9.29
0
+
-

Cheddar, White Sharp

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 10.69
0
+
-

Cheddar, White Medium

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 10.29
0
+
-

Cheddar, White Extra Sharp

Approximately 1 lb per package. Price is an estimate and based on exactly 1.00 lbs. Exact price will vary.
$ 10.59
0
+
-
× The product has been added to your shopping cart.